-
Conclusions and Recommendations for Further Work
Discussions within and outside the ETC/CDS consortium in the last months have
shown that awareness for terminological issues is rising, yet in some cases
not high enough. The user-friendliness of the interface of the terminology
database and its WWW access will be important for the acceptance of the tools
in preparation.
Currently the prototype terminology database is being prepared for access via
WWW.
The conclusion to be drawn from chapter 6 on copyright issues with respect to
terminological data is that the strategy needs to be flexible and broad-based:
the present situation is unsatisfactory in general as far as the regulation of I
PR issues for machine-readable terminology is concerned, which is why many
institutions possessing relevant and high-quality data are not willing and/or
allowed to make their data available, i.e. accessible in electronic form (on
data carriers or via telematic access) (either for free, against cost recovery
or on a commercial basis in the case of private companies). The Guide to
Terminology Agreements (Galinski/Goebel 1996) will provide help in this
unclear situation when negotiating with various institutions. The awareness
campaign will certainly contribute to an increased readiness of institutions
concerned to feed their data into the environmental terminology cooperation
framework that is emerging in the context of EIONET and beyond. Active
participation in and coordination with existing networks in the terminology
and language industry field (e.g. ELRA, the newly founded European Language
Resource Association, other European and international networks, and relevant
institutions)
Proposals for Future Work
From July/August 1996 onwards, continuous work on the tasks described above is needed:
- task 1: further development and refinement of strategies;
- task 2: improvement of data model on the basis of pilot test phase
of Enviroterm. Population of database (integration of existing resources
and/or WWW-links to them; collaborative work on new data, e.g. according to
needs of other ETCs, of CDS users);
- task 3: continuous extention of reference catalogue; making it
available in WWW
- task 4: receive comments on manual by its users and refine it
- task 5 (new task): EIONET/EEA- wide Internet discussion group on
terminological and concpeptual issues
The relation to other CBs of the ETC, to other ETCs and to EEA in general is
of particular importance,
- within ETC/CDS:
- CB 5, Thesaurus:
mutual benefit: CB 4 creates and/or integrates terminologies that are
potentially useful as microthesauri in the main thesaurus or for improving
conceptual structures, multilingual equivalences and linguistic expressions in
any part of the thesaurus.
- CB 6-9, CDS and EIONET integration:
on-line dictionary for CDS users (with definitions etc.) - totally
independent from the thesaurus!!
- in the opposite direction, CBs 5 to 9 give valuable information on which terminologies are needed, how existing ones are perceived by users, etc.
- to other ETCs: the main role of CB 4 is to contribute to a common
multilingual communication basis among different ETCs and for their specific
technical work by providing technical and methodological solutions for
managing and efficiently using terminologies and coding systems (horizontal
coordination of cooperation);
- to the EEA: a multilingual database with reliable information on key
concepts of environmental knowledge will be available and facilitate any work
(including the preparation of any kind of documentation, discourse and
information exchange among partners).
The following activities seem to be important for the ETC/CDS:
WWW Access to Terminology Database
-
Exploration and Evaluation of Existing and Environmentally Relevant Terminology Resources in WWW
This task will be a continuous one and also concerns parts of databases
accessible via WWW and other telematic means (ftp, Telnet, direct host access,
etc.). Criteria used for the evaluation include thematic and linguistic
coverage, overall quality and quality of individual definitions, equivalences,
usability for and relevance to EEA community, etc.
-
Population of the Terminology Database
This is also a continuous process including the direct inclusion of entries in
the database and the (indirect) reference to existing databases (or parts
thereof), by creating WWW-links to those resources that are selected under task
2.1.
In the first phase, a critical mass of entries directly included are to be
reached by integrating resources offered by project partners, e.g. from Norway,
Sweden, Denmark, Italy, Austria. The technical process includes conversion of
data from different source formats into a single target format. ISO DIS 12200
and ISO DIS 12620 are used in this phase.
-
Terminological Support to CB 5
According to precisely formulated requirements from the CB 5 project team
terminological support will be given, focussing on solving individual problems
in all languages concerned, e.g. on definitions, multilingual equivalences,
delimiting synonyms, selecting preferred terms, closely related concepts,
concept systems, support in the creation of microthesauri and authority lists
(e.g. on geographical names).
Coding
- Evaluation of Coding Systems Used in EIONET Databases
In order to harmonize the use of coding systems in such databases, those coding
systems actually used are evaluated according to criteria of general
applicability, their acceptance and quality. In this phase the requirements of
the CDS are of particular importance (e.g. concerning the data element concepts
used).
- Coding Guidelines
Based on the results of task 3.1 guidelines will be formulated for all EIONET
databases, based on their specific structures (in particular their data element
concepts and the relations between them) and applications, in order to reach
consistent use of one and the same data element concept in any database.
Internet Discussion Group on Environmental Terminology
- Establishment and Organization
This discussion group is established as a subscription list on the CEDAR server
and will eventually consist of four subgroups, in order to make sure that
specific goals are not blurred by the imminent danger of Internet-gossiping:
- CB4-internal group limited to partners active in CB4
- ETC/CDS-internal group limited to partners of the consortium
- EIONET-group limited to all institutions active in EIONET
- international group open to all persons interested
- Coordination and Management
The success of these sub-lists depends on strict management and efficient
coordination and moderation by the server organization. While some issues will
have to be discussed within a particular subgroup, other issues gain value
from a general discussion in all subgroups. Exploitation of results of these
discussions is also to be done by the server organization.
-
Reference Persons for National, Linguistic and Thematic Coverage
Such reference persons selected may be included in one or several of the
subgroups and should represent linguistic communities and national communities,
but also subject field knowledge (if possible in muliple combination thereof).
Terminology Awareness Campaign within EIONET
-
Focus on Ministries of Environment and other Relevant Administrative Units, National Focal Points
While awareness of terminological issues is often missing in such bodies,
others are well aware and active in this respect. It is expected to convince
such units to start national awareness campaigns on terminological issues.
-
Focus on WWW Dissemination
WWW should be the default means of dissemination. This means to coordinate the
creation of relevant homepages or the addition of coordinated information in
existing homepages (in the languages concerned).
-
ETC/CDS Newsletter
In each issue of this newsletter, an article on terminological problems and
solutions should be included. The organization running the Internet discussion
group is responsible for coordinating the preparation of such articles, taking
into consideration current issues and priorities of the ETC/CDS and EIONET.
The use and implementation of European (CEN) and international (ISO) standards
in the fields of environment and of terminology are of particular importance in
performing these tasks.
The application of new WWW-technologies such as JAVA an CORBA will be
investigated in the immediate future for the implementation concerning access
to a central (local) terminology database to be implemented on the WWW-server.
Back to Contents